Bourbon Buttermilk Layer Cake (one huge slice of cake)
This cake isn’t particularly bourbon-y per se, but rather the bourbon adds a certain toasty je ne sais quoi that helps set this apart from a straight up vanilla cake. If you don’t have any bourbon, obviously you must not live in Kentucky.
Just kidding. This recipe is highly forgiving with variations. It’s a crazy good way to use up flat champagne. Who knew? So use what you’ve got, provided it doesn’t sound like a stupid idea.
1 vanilla bean split and scraped, seeds reserved
4 ounces bourbon
14 ounces sugar
1 Tbsp baking powder
3/4 tsp baking soda
1 tsp kosher salt
1 tsp almond extract
1/2 tsp freshly grated nutmeg
8 ounces unsalted butter, room temp
5 eggs, room temp (important!)
2 egg yolks
13.5 ounces all purpose flour, sifted
13 ounces buttermilk
One day before: combine the bourbon and vanilla bean together in a small pot. Bring to a boil, shut off the heat, and cover. Steep overnight. Of course you can cheat and cut the time down to whatever is convenient for your circumstances, but your mileage may vary.
Preheat the oven to 350°
Combine the sugar through butter, along with reserved vanilla bean seeds in a mixing bowl. Use a paddle attachment to cream them together for ten minutes on medium speed. Seriously. Ten minutes. (I eschew the “until light and fluffy” schtick, I mean, how subjective is that?)
Every three or so minutes, stop the mixer and scrape the bowl down completely.
Turn the mixer down to medium low and while it’s running, add the eggs and then yolk, one at a time, mixing after each until thoroughly combined.
Turn the mixer down to the lowest speed and add in the sifted flour a cup at a time. Immediately add the bourbon (minus the bean itself) and slowly pour in the buttermilk.
Once you’ve finished adding the buttermilk, shut off the mixer and finish incorporating with a spatula.
To make the “slice of cake” cake from All Your Cake Are Belong To Us, use a 12” cake pan lined with parchment and lightly greased.
Otherwise bake off as 2 1/2 dozen cupcakes or use 3, 8” cake pans (prepared as described above). Don’t do this in two cake pans or you’ll have to clean up a cake volcano. Three pans.
Pour the batter into the prepared pan or pans (about 19.75 ounces per 8” round or 1/3 cup of batter per cupcake) and bake for 30-35 minutes, until lightly browned. If you press the surface gently with your fingertips, it should still leave a slight impression.
Great with Milk Chocolate Buttercream or any other variation thereof. If making a traditional layer cake and not a giant slice-o-cake, check out my crumb coating tutorial for more details on how to frost the cake.
For information on how to store the finished cake, see this post from the Kitchn.
Sep 12, 2011 · 1:10 PM
Hi Stella! This cake sounds amazing. I have a question – do you think another frosting would work as well? I’m going to make this cake for my mom’s birthday, but she’s not crazy about milk chocolate (she prefers dark), and she’s even claiming that she doesn’t want a buttercream (gasp!) because of all the delicious butter calories. She suggested a dark chocolate ganache, but I thought that a dark chocolate might overpower the delicateness of the cake. A vanilla buttercream would work, flavor-wise, but might be… boring? What do you think?
Sep 12, 2011 · 2:44 PM
@Kat, you could make the buttercream with all dark chocolate, and I don’t think that would overwhelm the flavor of the cake. The butter/sugar would keep the flavor profile from being too overwhelming for the cake itself. I’ve made it that way before too.
Calorically speaking, I don’t know that there’s any real benefit to ganache vs buttercream (if that’s her true concern). Buttercream gets half its volume from meringue, which is fat free, but also less calorically dense than cream or butter. Whereas ganache gets half its volume from cream, which packs a fairly hefty punch. I’m no nutritionalist, so that’s a layman’s analysis. But, if she simply isn’t too wild about buttercream and would just rather have ganache, it would certainly be delicious. A touch overpowering, perhaps, but your mom may appreciate using the cake as a vehicle/excuse to consume a heap of dark ganache, in which case it would be a great birthday present. Happy Birthday to her! Let me know how the cake turns out!
Sep 12, 2011 · 3:57 PM
You know, I thought the same thing about the cream in the ganache vs. the butter in the buttercream. I’ll probably end up trying the cake out with both ahead of time. Because, you know, I need an excuse to make more cake.
I’ve just started reading your blog, and I love it! Your recipes all sound so complex and interesting, and the pics are amazing. Also, I love reading a well-written food blog by a fellow Southern gal. P.S. You’re making me totally want to move to Kentucky!
Sep 13, 2011 · 12:19 PM
@Kat, Southern gals unite! So glad you found me and are enjoying the blog. But definitely, you should make as much cake as possible. I mean, it’s what a good daughter would do.
Jan 26, 2012 · 2:05 PM
@YogaAndBirth, hey girlie! There is a picture of it, actually on my facebook page (good thing we’re friends!). John made it last year for my birthday. Sorry to be bumming you out with the gluten, but I do have a TON of GF recipes here (about 75% of my recipes are), so you should be able to find something yummy!
Jun 01, 2012 · 12:24 AM
Hi Stella – I would like to employ your vanilla infused bourbon technique for a bourbon pecan pie I’m making tomorrow This particular pie recipe doesn’t call for vanilla in any form but it does use 1/2 tsp of grated lemon peel for an interesting kick. I figured some vanilla would a nice addition and don’t see any reason the infused booze would hinder my results or clash with the hint of lemon. Thoughts?
Jun 01, 2012 · 11:12 AM
@Kate, some people don’t like the flavor of lemon and vanilla because vanilla’s deeper notes tend to counteract lemon’s bright ones. You might try using a Tahitian vanilla, it has a brighter, floral note that might work better with the lemon. But it depends on what you want your end result to be. If you want the lemon to stand out, I think the vanilla might be distracting. But I’m a vanilla with pecans sort of girl, so I’d rather play up vanilla than lemon. Let your taste buds guide you!
Jun 01, 2012 · 8:47 PM
Thanks for the advice. I think my gut knew that and is why I asked. My head tried convincing me it’d be okay. I like to get carried away with additions. I have to remember less is more… I’m going to forgo the lemon and use the vanilla bourbon still sitting my on stovetop from last night : )
Jun 02, 2012 · 12:02 PM
@Kate C, vanilla, bourbon and nuts, you can’t go wrong! Although I’m admittedly biased, lemon’s not one of my favorites. But so long as you’re following your palate, it’ll work out. Thanks for the kind words, happy baking!
Jul 03, 2012 · 8:56 AM
@Aimee, I’m sure it will turn out just fine! It’s in the second step, “Combine the sugar through butter” so starting with sugar and every ingredient in this list through butter gets added together. I like doing it that way because it mixes all of the other ingredients so thoroughly during the creaming stage, but it works the other way too. I hope you enjoyed your cake!
Sep 17, 2012 · 9:48 AM
Hi Mickey! I say, give the teetotalers tea! I’d use black tea with a short steep time, maybe just 2 minutes. Perhaps an Assam? That would give you some of the warm, oak-y flavors without the booze.
Nov 04, 2012 · 10:54 AM
Hi Marian. Impromptu wedding?! How fun! Happy baking!!
Nov 14, 2012 · 6:54 PM
Hi luv2cook! I like to let my cakes cool in the pans all the way. If you’re using parchment on the bottom, I’d say to do the same. If you’ve just greased, or greased and floured, the bottoms, turn the cakes out onto a cooling rack after letting them cool for about ten minutes so they don’t stick. Hope that helps!
Nov 15, 2012 · 12:03 AM
No problem! Sounds like you’re baking up a storm. I don’t think you can double this recipe, unless you’ve got an industrial mixer. It will nearly fill up a Kitchen Aid bowl as it is. You might try baking it in two 10” cake pans; if you cut smallish portions, I think it would do for 30 (especially if there were other desserts, or ice cream, etc). But if you want to have big slices, you’d need to make it twice, or make another cake to supplement.
Nov 15, 2012 · 11:01 PM
i halved the recipe to fit it into 2 6 inch pans for a friend’s (4 people gathering) bday..and you know how when you take them out of the pans and there are some moist crumbs stuck on the sides? i scraped at them, and boy were they YUMMY!!! I think i’m going to add some espresso powder to dark chocolate buttercream for the frosting thanks for the recipe, stella!
· megan · whyisfoodsogood.blogspot.com
Nov 16, 2012 · 6:35 AM
Hi Megan. Muahahaha, I know exactly what you mean. Those things are so, so good. My husband always gets angry if I throw them away…
Nov 17, 2012 · 7:54 PM
Hey again. All the buttercreams here are more or less equal in piping. They do great for piping borders (shells and pearls) and dots and writing, but they aren’t very good for roses (because they stay soft). So just let your taste buds be your guide and whatever you choose will work well for your purposes. Good luck!
Jan 13, 2013 · 6:47 PM
I have a Butter cake recipe that I used for all my wedding cakes but have found that I always have a lot of tunneling even though I only mix to incorporate after the 10 minute creaming process. Is this cake your standard yellow cake? Mine is the butter cake but I am wondering if this might have a better crumb to it.
Jan 13, 2013 · 8:52 PM
Is this cake your go to yellow cake? I used a buttercake recipe for my wedding cakes but found the crumb is not as fine as I like. I realize this is probably due to overmixing but the taste is really good and no one ever noticed. I didn’t see a yellow type basic cake on your blog so thought I would ask.
Jan 14, 2013 · 12:12 AM
Hi Joan! It’s not super “yellow” but this is a go-to butter cake recipe for me. Tunneling can occur for a variety of reasons beyond over mixing, so that may not necessarily be to blame. A batter that’s too stiff (ie, not enough liquids) or too cold can also result in tunneling, in my experience. That might help you diagnose what’s going on in your recipe, if nothing else. Cheers!
Mar 25, 2013 · 9:49 AM
I made this cake with the caramel variation of the swiss buttercream for my mom’s birthday. It turned out great. I was just wondering if you think a variation of this cake could be used for a coconut cake. Would it be possible to switch out the bourbon or some of the buttermilk with coconut milk?
Mar 25, 2013 · 10:16 PM
Hi Jessica! Generally, I’m all about variations, but this cake has a very fussy balance of ingredients, and I’ve noticed that messing around with the bourbon and buttermilk can really hurt the final texture of the cake. I’ve played around with coconut milk myself, and while it works well in most other recipes, it doesn’t turn out well with this one.
Apr 13, 2014 · 12:00 AM
I made this cake again, this time for my husband’s birthday..and it was weird because among other things, I saw BIG CO2 holes when I trimmed the top before frosting. the cake scraps had a nice and fluffy texture, but the rest of the cake had a few tiny tunnels and it was more dense with some sections w/ “gummy” looking cake like this : http://www.angerburger.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/DSC_7385.jpg (not my picture but it shows you my point)! do you think this was a mixing issue? my hypothesis was that I undermixed at some point after the flour or buttermilk/bourbon addition, so that the top part of the cake was ok but the bottom didn’t get enough leavening so did not rise as well? what do you think? a penny for your thoughts, if you please! thank you!
· megan · whyisfoodsogood.blogspot.com
Apr 13, 2014 · 9:21 PM
Hi megan! Hmm, there’s a few things that might be going on. Tunneling and holes can be a result of a batter that’s too cold (from cold butter, cold eggs, etc), but over and undermixing can also be an issue. The fact that there was some density makes me think of temperature as an issue, as cold batter won’t whip up as light…. Any of that ring a bell with your experience?
Apr 28, 2014 · 4:40 PM
Hi again (wrote one message already tonight),
Sorry, I don`t mean to selfishly keep you busy, but I would like to ask you for one big favour – I just cannot decide fot a cake for my 8 year old upcoming holy communion so I thought that when I say she doesn`t like too sweet taste (that is number one), she likes dark chocolate things like death by chocolate (possibly), or also light vanilla buttery cakes, possibly some coconut shreads and touch of caramel. What combo from your lovely recipes would work great together for simple yet moist and not too sweet combination likable by a child.
Thanks so so much for your advice. I appreciate your time and consideration.
Apr 29, 2014 · 1:16 PM
Hi kata! No trouble at all, I’m happy to help. You might try making my Chocolate Cranberry Cake and pairing it with my German Buttercream. You can make the buttercream with an equal amount of unsweetened coconut milk instead of regular milk. That would give her the dark chocolate flavor she loves, but with the lightness of coconut for balance. What do you think?
Apr 29, 2014 · 1:16 PM
thanks for writing back to me! hmm….i’m pretty sure i cheated and started out with cold butter i don’t recall what the temp of my eggs were. but, next time i’ll make sure to have room temp ingredients and will let you know how i fare i have a 1-1 track record of success:fail so far; let’s hope i can make it 2-1! thanks for your help.
· megan · whyisfoodsogood.blogspot.com
May 05, 2014 · 5:15 PM
Hi megan! Oh yeah, I’m sure you’ll have better results with room temperature butter. It doesn’t need to be mush, but soft and pliable at least. It helps the batter expand to trap more air, whereas cold/hard butter can’t incorporate as much and so becomes gummy. Happy baking!
May 13, 2014 · 10:52 AM
Hi Stella, I have had so much success with this cake and the chocolate buttercream…raves. I am wondering if a caramel would be too sweet or maybe the apple cider version to add to SMB would be better. I must confess, super sweet is not my guilty pleasure so I am not the best one to sort this out. Thanks so much.
May 21, 2014 · 11:29 AM
Hi Mickey! I’m so glad you’ve enjoyed this cake! I think a salted caramel frosting would offset the cake much like the bitterness of chocolate in the versions you’ve previously made. Just salt the caramel buttercream to taste (maybe melt a Tablespoon of buttercream and dissolve the salt in that first, before whipping it into the BC), and perhaps use a scrap of cake trimmed from the dome as a tasting guide.
May 29, 2014 · 1:18 PM
Sorry to bother you with questions. See, as a brazilian I have no clue what to expect from “yellow cake” or “white cake” as these are american terms. Because I’ve researched a whole lot I’m familiar with the terms, but not the tastes and textures. I do have experience with cakes, however. I love the buttery cakes we call “cake flavored cakes” in Brazil. I have a recipe I always go back to, which’s got a fine crumb and tender texture I love, but I find it’s taste somewhat one-dimentional for some applications. I was looking for something a little more “grown-up” and less sweet, and your cake seems to fit the bill perfectly (and deliciously). I have a few questions tough. I intend to swap the burbon for an aged cachaça, a spirit make from sugarcane. I don’t think this will be a problem in terms of ingredient balance and I’m sure it’ll taste great. The thing is, buttermilk just isn’t a thing in Brazil. I can’t find it anywhere. There is no local equivalent. I’ve make recipes which called for buttermilk swapping it for soured milk (full fat milk and a mild vinager or lime juice) and yogurt. I’ve also had success eliminating baking soda, upping baking powder and swapping buttermilk for straight milk, tough I did miss the tang buttermilk would contribute with.
What do you think is the best game plan in this situation? Should I try soured milk? If so, using vinager or lime/lemon juice (lemons are expensive and inconsistent over here, while limes are plenty and juicy, and I think the amount needed to sour the milk won’t make a huge difference flavor wise)? Do you have any other idea for subistituting the buttermilk in your recipe? Or maybe… Do you think I should give up on your recipe alltogether and find another which doesn’t use ingredients I don’t have?
· Maria · Naturalcomo.wordpress.com
May 30, 2014 · 8:03 AM
Wow, I just realized how much I wrote! Sorry!!
And all I wanted to know was how to sub the buttermilk.. I’m really sorry.
· Maria · Naturalcomo.wordpress.com
May 30, 2014 · 2:54 PM
Hi Maria! Omg, no worries my friend. It only looks long because the comment columns are so skinny. Yellow cake is traditionally made from egg yolks, white cake is made from egg whites, and cakes made with whole eggs tend to fall under a wide variety of names, like “butter cake.” White cakes are the fluffiest, with a pronounced vanilla flavor; yellow cakes are more tender and fine, with a custard flavor from all the yolks, and butter cakes split the difference. So this cake is a bit of a hybrid, using whole eggs and a few yolks. It is finely textured and very buttery, with some complexity of flavor from the bourbon and vanilla.
I’ve had good luck using non-fat yogurt as a substitute for buttermilk, is that something you can get a hold of? (Buttermilk is the leftovers of the butter making process, so it is a naturally fat free.) If not, try a “sour milk” made from lowfat or skim milk and lime juice. I’ve never tried this myself, so I’m afraid I can’t vouch for the results in this recipe, but there’s reasonably good evidence it would work.
May 31, 2014 · 9:21 AM
Fat-free yogurt seems reasonable! I’ll try that if I can find a thickener-free brand. Otherwise I’ll go with the soured skim milk.
Oh, and reporting back: I had great success with you german buttercream recipe! Delicious and very “homey” taste, much lighter than creme musseline!! All in all SMB is still my favourite, but it’s nice to have options. I made it coffee-flavored (steeped the milk with coffee beans at the begening and added strong strong brewed coffee in the end) and frosted a simple chocolate cake and it was a hit. Thank you!
· Maria · Naturalcomo.wordpress.com
May 31, 2014 · 3:42 PM
Hi Maria! I’m so thrilled you liked the German buttercream. I love being able to steep different ingredients in the milk for a deeper flavor, so glad you gave that a shot. Good luck with the yogurt-cake!
Sep 20, 2014 · 11:43 PM
Hi Stella! I’ve just made this recipe in cupcake form and it turned out soft and fluffy! Only change I made was to replace bourbon with the blueberry reduction on your website for blueberry cupcakes all of them shunk away from the liners upon leaving the oven though – is that due to me overbeating the batter after adding the eggs? Would greatly appreciate your help, Stella! Thanks so much!
Oct 19, 2014 · 10:48 AM
Hey Stella! This cake sounds incredible, I cannot believe how much bourbon you squeezed in here! I was wondering, my brother doesn’t really like chocolate (gasp! I know) so how do you think a vanilla buttercream would work with this? Any other flavor suggestions? Thanks so much!